If there’s one type of ride fit to adorn the flag of the Lone Star State – it’s the pickup, by and far. In fact, according to the TxDMV report from 2021, Texas has the highest absolute number of pickup trucks of any other US state – 6.15 million or approximately 1 per every 5 residents.

Of course, this comes as no surprise. The State’s rich ranching heritage, vast expanses, and well-developed agricultural industry (and Texans’ love for powerful rides) make pickups an essential part of everyday life – both in terms of work and personal use.

However, this also means that choosing the right type of truck will be what makes or breaks the experience. One of the biggest decisions you’ll have to make is whether you’ll go for a gas or diesel variant when buying a pickup from used car dealers in Port Arthur.

While you definitely won’t lack in the coolness department regardless of the option you choose, ultimately, the practicality is what matters. So, let’s explore the pros and cons of both options, so you can make an informed decision and pick up the right pickup!

Is it better to get a gas truck or a diesel truck?

TL;DR: It depends on how you intend to use it.

  • For heavy towing, lots of highway miles, and long-term ownership, diesel often takes the cake.
  • For lighter use, lower upfront cost, and cheaper maintenance costs, gas is typically a better choice.

Now, let’s dive deeper and break down the “whys” behind the above statements.

What are the advantages of a diesel truck?

Diesel trucks hold several significant advantages over their gasoline counterparts, especially if they’re being used as work machines:

  • Better haulers: Diesel engines produce strong low-end torque (i.e., high torque at low RPMs), which makes getting moving with heavy loads/tows much easier and less strenuous on the drivetrain.
  • Better fuel economy (under load and on highway): On average, diesels return more miles per gallon when towing/hauling and when cruising at steady speeds.
  • Longer engine life: Since they operate at lower RPMs and are generally built more ruggedly, diesel engines tend to last longer than gas ones – sometimes hundreds of thousands of miles more (with proper maintenance, of course).
  • Higher resale value (for heavy-use buyers): Unsurprisingly, well-maintained diesels tend to retain value better with buyers looking for a powerful hauler.
  • Broad fuel availability: Diesel is widely available in both rural and urban areas of Texas (which cannot be said for many other US states).

We have one “special case” that needs addressing separately. Namely, you’ll often hear that diesel rides require less servicing than gasoline ones. This is a half-truth, but backed by a few facts: 

  • Diesels don’t have spark plugs, so you won’t have to change them, ever.
  • Oil changes can be stretched further between (e.g., 7,500 – 10,000 miles compared to gas engines’ 5,000 – 7,500 miles).
  • Heavy-duty components make diesel engines last longer before needing rebuilds or overhauls (with proper maintenance).

However, diesels also add some recurring servicing requirements, including fuel filter changes, DEF (Diesel Exhaust Fluid) refills, DPF (Diesel Particulate Filter) care, and turbo/high-pressure fuel system, which can add cost/complexity to servicing.

What are the advantages of a gas truck?

What are the advantages of a gas truck

While diesels make a strong case, gasoline-powered engines have a lot of great things going for them as well:

  • Lower upfront investment: On average, gas-based models cost less up front than their diesel equivalents.
  • Lower routine maintenance costs: Gas engine parts and servicing are generally cheaper, making them more suitable for casual owners.
  • Cheaper fuel: Historically, the price of gasoline (per gallon) has been lower. On the flip side, diesels do boast better MPG, meaning that the amount of savings depends on usage.
  • Better for short trips: While diesels excel on open roads, gas engines tolerate short trips and stop-and-go driving much better, making them more suitable for cities.
  • More budget options: If you need a reliable work truck on a budget, gas variants offer more model choices at lower trims.

Diesel trucks vs. gas trucks: a quick comparison

Here’s a tabular side-by-side comparison of diesel and gas trucks for quick reference:

FactorDiesel trucksGasoline trucks
Upfront priceHigher (premium for diesel option)Lower (cheaper base price)
Fuel economy (under load/highway)Better MPG, especially when towingLower MPG; worse under heavy load
Torque & towing feelHigh low-end torque – excellent for towingLower torque at low RPMs – towing is more strenuous for the engine
Long-term durabilityOften longer-lived if maintained properlyGood, but may not reach the same high mileages as diesel
Maintenance complexityMore complex (DEF, DPF, turbo, higher-pressure fuel system)Simpler emissions systems (generally)
Maintenance costPotentially higher for major repairs; routine parts priceyGenerally lower routine repair costs
Fuel price variabilityDiesel price per gallon is sometimes higher, but offset by MPGGas is often cheaper per gallon, but returns lower MPG
Short trips / city drivingLess ideal (DPF regen issues without longer, steady-state runs)Better suited to stop-and-go and short trips
Resale value (tow/heavy use)Usually higherModerate; depends on buyer
Environmental regs/complexityModern diesels have strict emissions tech (cost/complexity)Emissions tech simpler; newer gas engines are complex (e.g., turbo, direct injection)
What are the advantages of a diesel truck

Which used car dealers near me in Port Arthur have high-quality pickup trucks for sale?

B.Y.O.T. pick-n-pull in Beaumont is the place to find the top deals on pre-owned vehicles in the Port Arthur vicinity. Whether you’re looking for your next project car, a budget-friendly electric ride, or a powerhouse pickup truck, chances are you will find it at our yard – and at a price that’s bound to make you grin. 

But beware – our stock is changing fast! So don’t wait – give us a call today or download our mobile app, and be the first to know when your dream ride hits our inventory!